Surprise arrival of VCAT decision
2 Liked

Early VCAT decision

Some emails should arrive with a fanfare – a call to arms on the bugle.  They catch your attention with a colourful display of fireworks to proudly announce their arrival!  They don’t drop quietly into the mail account with a faint whisper of electrons being rearranged in some faraway server.  I’m thinking about the email we just received from VCAT (Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal).

VCAT decision on our neighbours’ appeal.

The VCAT email explained the tribunal had given leave for our neighbours to withdraw their objection which was stopping the Council releasing our Planning Permit.  A few weeks ago, next door received a letter from the Council explaining how the proposed drainage works would cause minimal impact on the trees near where the new trench would be dug.  That was the last we heard about the matter.  It was radio silence from our neighbours.

Out of the blue, VCAT advised us the appeal no longer existed.  Great news!

Response to VCAT decision

VCAT granted our neighbours’ request to withdraw their application.  As a result, the Council is now free to release our Planning Permit as per their original intention.  The August 30 hearing is cancelled.

The language in the letter is strong.  “This decision is final and binding unless it is set aside by the Supreme Court …

We will check with our legal team in case there is something we missed.  Getting blind-sided by the VCAT appeal means we are wary of taking things at face value.  Is there something else our neighbours might raise at a later date?

Moving on from VCAT.

So, for now, it’s back to business.

David was excited to hear the news.  He wants to begin dismantling this house on September 1.  We’re excited to think that things will be happening this year.  A cleared site means we start building the front unit and the Council installs their drainage pipe.

To do list after VCAT decision

There’s a lot to do.  Here’s a sample from our to-do list.

  • Finalise the Planning Permit so we officially move on to the Building Permit.
  • Move out of here and into a nearby rental property during construction of the first unit.
  • Sort out the details of how/when the Council will carry out their drainage excavation in order to better coordinate the two projects.
  • Get into the nitty-gritty of detailed design for our homes so these decisions become the basis for accurate cost estimates.

This is a daunting list but, at the same time, it’s satisfying to know everything we do will be moving us towards the ultimate goal of three attractive, sustainable homes.


  • Gillian Cohen

    July 02, 07 2017 07:52:25

    Yay! Fantastic news. Onwards and upwards.

  • Anne Thompson

    July 02, 07 2017 09:41:52

    Congratulations to you! What a fantastic result after much patient waiting.
    (Hoping you won’t demolish until you have a building permit too.)
    Champagne time, and onwards.

  • Jean Robinson

    July 02, 07 2017 11:06:59

    That’s the best news yet. Bet you can’t wait to get cracking!

  • peter

    July 03, 07 2017 07:05:05

    Great to see common sense prevail (supposedly). When you move out to rent, you shouldn’t even have to change your postal address, maybe not even a redirection.

Leave a Reply